A Review of From Criticism of the Document to the Criticism of the Text (Pt.۱)

Muhammad Javedan

This article reviews the article: From Criticism of the Document to the criticism of the Text written by Dr. Hanafi, which six parts of it has yet been published in this Journal (Ulum-i Hadith). While mentioning the history of compiling hadith, the author tries to display the shortcomings which exist in Dr. Hanafi’s article and raises some objections on Dr. Hanafi doctrines the next part of this review will be published in the next issue of this journal.

Key Words: Document Criticism, Text Criticism, History of Compiling Hadith.

Click Here to read the Original Paper